Through her 2022 debut, Hayden Silas Anhedönia, also known by her stage name, Ethel Cain, introduces us to the greatest tragic story of the last 100 years.
Scene: 1991, a young girl in the fictional town of Shady Grove, Alabama, lives with her mother - she’s a Southern Baptist Christian, and the daughter of a preacher who died in a fire 10 years prior. Listeners click play on the record and hear the words “these crosses all over my body remind me of who I used to be” sung, not realising that over the next 75 minutes, they’ll be hearing Cain illustrate her life story, from tragic heartbreak to literal murder and cannibalism.
On ‘American Teenager’, Cain criticises the concept of an American Dream in an anti-war protest track that sounds like it just came straight out of the 80s, which was ironically included on former President Barack Obama’s ‘favourite songs of 2022’ list. ‘A House in Nebraska’ is a heartfelt ballad, mourning the disappearance of her one true love, Willoughby Tucker, who Anhedönia then goes on to create a prequel LP about in 2025. ‘Family Tree’ showcases Cain revealing a family secret – the preacher, her father, was not as good a man as everyone believed, continuing onto ‘Hard Times’ where she lulls about the sexual abuse and trauma she faced as a child at the hands of her own father (“I was too young to notice that some kinds of love could be bad).
Entering the second act of the album, ‘Thoroughfare’, a nine-and-a-half minute, country-influenced indie rock epic, displays Anhedönia’s meticulous skill with her songcraft, entirely written and produced by her. In the storyline, she meets a man named Isaiah on a thoroughfare, and she joins him on his journey to California. Following a three-minute long session of Cain scatting, ‘Gibson Girl’ changes the tune completely. Cain falls under the guise of Isaiah, and gets drugged and pimped out at the back of a Texan strip club once Isaiah reveals his true intentions.
At this point in the record, a first-time listener may not realise the sharp turn that this story is about to take. ‘Ptolemaea’ is no less than terrifying; it’s a horror movie within a song. Still under the influence of Isaiah’s drugs, Cain realises that she is going to die. Three different perspectives come out of this track; we first hear from Isaiah himself (“There’s nothing you can do, it’s already been done”), then from Cain, (“What fear a man like you brings upon a woman like me”), and lastly, from a personification of Death, (“Run then, child, you can’t hide from me forever”). Sonically, it transitions from a quiet, ambient atmosphere to a chaotic, doom metal soundscape. The following two tracks, ‘August Underground’ (named after the snuff film of the same name) and ‘Televangelism’ are both fully instrumental, and depict Cain’s ascension to Heaven after her passing. The penultimate song, ‘Sun Bleached Flies’, is Cain reminiscing on her life before (“I spend my life watching it go by from the sidelines”), thinking through all of the things that she would have done differently (“And God, I’ve tried, but I think it’s about time I put up a fight”). Accepting her fate, (“If it’s meant to be, then it will be”), she sends one final love note to the only man she really wanted: Willoughby (“I’m still praying for that house in Nebraska, by the highway out on the edge of town”). The album then finishes with the final track, ‘Strangers’, where Anhedönia closes the story with a final five minutes of Cain begging to become something – (“I tried to be good, am I no good?”). In the final forty seconds, she gives one last message to her mother, (“Mama, just know that I love you, and I’ll see you when you get here”).
In summary, ‘Preacher’s Daughter’ is one of the most illustrative, creative, and spellbinding concept albums released this decade. Not many are able to fully write and produce an album, especially not one this complex, let alone create an entire fictional universe to accompany it.
In the years since the release of the LP, Cain has reached levels of success even she never imagined, managing to chart in the top 10 of the Billboard 200, becoming the first openly transgender artist to reach the milestone. Additionally, the album has a score of 82/100 on Metacritic, and was featured on several critics’ ‘Best Albums of 2022’ lists, peaking atop three of them. She also revealed plans to create an album trilogy based on the Ethel Cain universe, with three different albums coming from the perspectives of Ethel’s mother, and Ethel’s grandmother. The only question is, where in the universe will she venture into next?